Critical Thinking

ISIL However, there are no information available on

ISIL members
have been committing various crimes and bombings in Iraq, and various cases
have been reported by Iraq and in the media. As part of ISIL crimes, ISIL
seized control of the city Mosul, a city rich in cash and gold in 2014. However,
in 2017, the Iraqi Prime Minister declared that Iraqi forces had retaken Mosul back
from ISIL. While Iraqi forces remain in progress in recapturing ISIL controlled
territory, Iraq has recently requested assistance from the United Nations with
regards to the investigation of crimes committed by ISIL1.
The purpose of the investigation needed is to support Iraqi domestic effort to
hold ISIL accountable for their criminal actions2.Thus, the
Security Council of the United Nations in its 8052nd meeting on 21 September 2017
has adopted a resolution requesting the UN Secretary-General to establish an investigatory
body to be headed by a Special Adviser3.
The role of the Team is to support domestic efforts to hold ISIL accountable
through collecting, preserving, and storing evidence of acts that may amount to
(1) war crimes; (2) crimes against humanity; (3) genocide; (4) atrocity crimes;
and (5) to work with survivors in a manner consistent with relevant national
laws in Iraq. While operating with full respect to Iraq’s sovereignty and
jurisdiction over the crimes committed on its territory. The mandate is to
ensure the broadest possible use of national courts, and for investigations to
be carried out by the Iraqi authorities or by authorities in third countries at
their request. Whereas,. In addition, the Security Council decided that the
UN Secretary-General should establish a trust fund to receive voluntary contributions
to implement the Resolution, and States to contribute by monetary means or by services.
Based on the said resolution, the Security Council
holds the right to review the mandate carried out by the investigatory team
after a period of two (2) years which may be extended upon a request from the
government of Iraq. However, there are no information available on whether the
fund has been established, and the framework of which the Security Council has
the right to review the investigatory team’s mandate.Unfortunately, as reported by the Human Rights
Watch4,
the Iraqi government faces challenges with regards to due process and fair
trial standards. Iraq is relying on counterterrorism courts to prosecute all
ISIL suspects mainly on the charge of membership in ISIS with no distinction
made for the severity of the charges. ISIS suspects have been identified based
on wanted lists and accusations by community members with no further evidence
which may result to misidentification and detention of non-affiliated members
to ISIL. Iraqi courts allows for death penalty for ISIL suspects, and the United
Nations policy does not support or assist processes that could lead to the
death penalty. Therefore, if the Iraqi government is unable to carry out the prosecution
of ISIL suspects based on evidence, due process and fair trial while suspending
the death penalty, the United Nations may not be able to support. Nonetheless, Iraq is not a member of the
International Criminal Court (ICC) which means that the international community
cannot examine the abuses made by the Iraqi’s security forces. As a result, Iraq’s
position to accomplish the object of the investigatory team might be weakened as
the United Nations have little to work with given Iraq’s position toward the death
penalty.

x

Hi!
I'm Simon!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out